In this charming story based on true events, MOTHER REBEKKAH has been baking Christmas cookies all day and arranges them in a lovely gift basket wrapped and tied with a red bow on top. A family Christmas tradition of baking and setting aside a special batch for Santa.

While Mother Rebekkah is picking up her children from school - MYA, CHARLIE, and JACOB, her basket is being broken into and the cookies taken. They are shocked upon entering the home to see cookies scattered in various places. The children immediately assume that Santa has been in their home early. However, the strange strewing of cookies throughout the house makes them suspicious.

Fearing that it was an intruder, the children act as detectives examining pieces of evidence to find out if it was Santa or an intruder of this mystery of the missing cookies with the help of Mother Rebekkah's husband, who is a firefighter who sets off the fire station alarm.

An investigation ensues to the children's delight as adults, firefighters and the captain of the fire station looked for clues to solve this mystery. Who could have taken the cookies? Follow Mother Rebekkah, Mya, Charlie, Jacob, and the firefighters as they unravel the mystery of this cookie heist.