Olivia's goal is within reach. She's been accepted to her dream school, Vanderbilt University, alma mater of famed comic illustrator Paige O'Donnell. Despite gaining multiple scholarships and grants, Olivia's just shy of tuition. Desperate, she applies for a $15,000 scholarship offered by the Wonderbrink Foundation, to be awarded to a high-achieving and athletic senior with diabetes. One little problem... Olivia doesn't have diabetes.

In her quest to pull off a whopper of a lie, Olivia attends a diabetes support group meeting, where she meets and befriends Paul Roberts, a smug yet handsome member of the Sugar Shatterers. Her best friends Xavier and Amber aren't thrilled about Olivia's new mysterious, one-sided friendship with superstitious, entitled Paul. Xavier may secretly be a *little* jealous, and the scholarship application deadline rapidly approaches.