Ten months after accepting the position of senior pastor at the West Aurora Baptist Church, forward-thinking Rev. Bradley White is questioning God. He does not fit-in with the traditional congregation.

West Aurora's newest member, Dr. Lori Reed asks too many questions. Based on her joining testimony, the organic chemist is assigned a series of common ministry tasks: ushering, childcare, and greeting guests. And she's failed at every one. According to some, there's no need for a chemist in the ministry.

Inspired by Lori's earnest desire to serve, Bradley tries to help Lori fit-in at West Aurora. And he soon discovers the perfect place for the super-smart-sister with the cute sprinkle of freckles across the bridge of her nose. In his arms.

After the misfit minister and questioning chemist fall in love, they struggle to remain at a church that doesn't embrace either one of them, until Grace Changes Everything.