Aspiring painter Gray Wilson and socialite Ashley York try to adjust back to their old lives after their surreal body-swapping experiences, but will anything ever truly be the same again? And now that they know of the incredible power held by the Encanto, can they resist the temptation to use it?

Meanwhile, Detective Saul Parker struggles to understand a bizarre string of murders, and nothing about his investigation is going well: the behavior of his prime suspect, Gray Wilson, is confusing, and after witnessing a shocking death up close, Saul casts suspicion on himself. Not only is he removed from the case, but he's suspended from the force. Worse, he has a strange gap in his memory that he can't explain.

With the help of his partner, Saul continues investigating off-duty, but things aren't adding up, and he realizes that he's dealing with forces beyond his comprehension. And there's one crazy idea he just can't shake: What if a murderer was able to control a person's body and use them like a puppet?