Rick Morrand, now sheriff of Dexter County, grows suspicious, especially when he learns that one of the fellow hunters, Randall Boone, is rumored to have had an affair with Garrett's wife, Amber. Rick also finds it troubling that Garrett and Boone had a fistfight in camp shortly before Garrett disappeared.
Amber, meanwhile, seems overly eager to get her hands on the proceeds of a substantial life insurance policy. When confronted, she claims that she needs the money to support her four-year-old disabled child, Gabe.
Early search efforts are complicated by a raging wildland fire. Garrett's belongings and possible remains are eventually found by a Search and Rescue dog whose attractive female handler knew Garrett well-maybe a little too well.
The discovery of bone fragments and an excessive amount of Garrett's blood make it hard to avoid concluding the bow hunter is dead. But how exactly did he die? Rick Morrand is hard-pressed to get answers in the midst of personal crises that threaten to distract him from getting to the truth.
Garrett McRae's disappearance becomes Rick's trial by fire as new sheriff-in more ways than one.