A Secret Amish Crush by Marta Perry

Lydia Stoltzfus is content being a maidal, unwed but happily running an Amish coffee shop. Until her schoolgirl crush returns home and she falls in love...with his timid five-year-old daughter. Widower Simon Fisher has no plans to remarry, especially not to his lighthearted former neighbor. But will devotion to a child--and a matchmaking community--show them their future is together?

The Amish Teacher's Wish by Tracey J. Lyons

With the school damaged during a storm, teacher Sadie Fischer needs Levi Byler's help repairing it. Levi has one condition--he won't become a part of her search for a husband. He's been hurt before, and love and marriage aren't in his plans. But Sadie might just be the perfect woman to mend his heart...and convince him forever isn't just for fairy tales.

Previously published as A Secret Amish Crush and The Amish Teacher's Wish