Twin sisters, Elma and Thelma Hochstetler do everything together. They live together, they run a general store in Indiana together, and they are growing old together--neither one marrying young like their peers. But that could change if one of them marries.

The Lopsided Christmas Cake
A baking flop still manages to earn high bids from admiring bachelors at an Amish charity auction when Elma and Thelma recreate their grandmother's Christmas cake recipe in front of a live audience. Will the highest bidder also win a sister's heart?

The Farmers' Market Mishap
Still single Elma wonders if she is just too picky to find love. Through a mishap at the farmers' market, Elma meets Ben Wagler and instantly likes him. But Elma has tried long-distance dating before, and it bound to end badly.