Macy never expected to find the love of her life in high school-at an 1800s pioneer reenactment camp, no less-but that's precisely where she met Nate. She was a private school kid reluctantly attending camp for the first time with her dad. Nate was from a large, homeschooling family that enjoyed going every year. Their unlikely friendship soon developed into a romantic relationship that had them dreaming of a future together-until Macy unexpectedly called things off in college.

Now twenty-three, Macy is a successful florist with no plans of settling down. When her best friend's wedding festivities mean Nate's return, she's forced to face her past and the feelings she may still have for him. Macy will have to decide if she's willing to risk opening her heart again, or if she will stay on the path she's already chosen where things feel safer.

Even When It Wasn't You is a closed door/low spice romance that includes mild language and some heavier themes, but ultimately ends with a swoon-worthy happily ever after. If you enjoy the wedding backdrop and dual timelines of Forget Me Not by Julie Soto but prefer the funny and wholesome writing style of Sarah Adams, you'll love Even When It Wasn't You. It will make you laugh, cry and stay up way past your bedtime.